Home / CIE 9702 Physics / Medical physics
CIE 9702 Physics · A Level · Topic 24

Medical physics

CIE 9702 PhysicsA LevelFree revision notes

Contents: 5 sections

Cambridge International AS & A Level Physics 9702 · A Level

Three imaging methods let doctors see inside the body without surgery, and each one applies physics from elsewhere in the course. Ultrasound uses reflection of sound at boundaries, X-ray imaging and CT use the attenuation of X-rays, and PET uses positron annihilation. This topic covers how each signal is produced, how it interacts with tissue, and how an image is formed. It is A Level content, examined on Paper 4, and draws on waves (topic 7), photons (topic 22) and radioactive decay and antiparticles (topics 11 and 23).

24.1 Production and use of ultrasound

The piezo-electric effect

A piezo-electric crystal, such as quartz or the ceramic lead zirconate titanate, has two linked properties:

The effect works in both directions, so a single crystal can be both the source and the detector of ultrasound. A device that does both is called a transducer.

Generating and detecting ultrasound

Ultrasound is longitudinal sound with a frequency above the range of human hearing, above 20 kHz. Medical scanners use roughly 1 to 15 MHz.

Generation. An alternating p.d. is applied across the crystal. The crystal expands and contracts at the frequency of the p.d., pushing and pulling on the material in contact with it, and so sends out a longitudinal wave of that frequency. The crystal is cut to a thickness whose natural frequency equals the applied frequency, so it resonates and the vibrations, and the ultrasound produced, have a large amplitude.

Detection. A returning ultrasound wave makes the crystal vibrate, alternately compressing and stretching it. This generates an alternating e.m.f. across the crystal at the frequency of the wave, which is amplified and processed. Its size indicates the intensity of the returning wave.

Pulses. The transducer sends out short pulses of ultrasound, not a continuous wave, because it cannot transmit and listen at the same time. After each pulse it acts as a receiver, and the next pulse is not sent until the echoes from the deepest structures have returned. A backing material damps the crystal so that each pulse is short, which allows boundaries close together to be distinguished.

High frequencies are used because the wavelength must be small for fine detail to be seen. In soft tissue, where the speed is about 1500 m s⁻¹, 3 MHz ultrasound has λ = 1500 / (3.0 × 10⁶) = 5.0 × 10⁻⁴ m, half a millimetre.

Obtaining diagnostic information from reflected pulses

When an ultrasound pulse meets a boundary between two tissues, part of it is reflected and the rest is transmitted onwards. Each boundary therefore sends back an echo.

An A-scan (amplitude scan) displays echo amplitude against time for one direction into the body. It is used to measure depths and thicknesses, for example in the eye. A B-scan (brightness scan) moves or sweeps the transducer across the body, converting each echo into a dot whose brightness shows its strength and whose position shows its depth. Combining many lines builds a two-dimensional image of internal structures, as in a pregnancy scan.

Ultrasound A-scan aligned with a depth scale. Top: probe and gel at the skin, then 1.5 cm of fat, muscle from 1.5 to 4.5 cm, and bone beyond. Bottom: echo amplitude against time; the transmitted pulse at 0 μs, a small echo at 20 μs from the fat to muscle boundary at 1.5 cm, and a large echo at 60 μs from the muscle to bone boundary at 4.5 cm, using depth = 1500 m/s × t / 2.
Ultrasound A-scan aligned with a depth scale. Top: probe and gel at the skin, then 1.5 cm of fat, muscle from 1.5 to 4.5 cm, and bone beyond. Bottom: echo amplitude against time; the transmitted pulse at 0 μs, a small echo at 20 μs from the fat to muscle boundary at 1.5 cm, and a large echo at 60 μs from the muscle to bone boundary at 4.5 cm, using depth = 1500 m/s × t / 2.

Worked example 1. An echo returns 60 μs after a pulse is sent into soft tissue, where the speed of ultrasound is 1500 m s⁻¹. How deep is the boundary?

Distance travelled by the pulse: 1500 × 60 × 10⁻⁶ = 0.09 m.

The boundary is at half this distance: 0.09 / 2 = 0.045, so depth = 4.5 cm. Forgetting to halve is the standard error.

Worked example 2, thickness of a layer. In the A-scan above, the echoes from the front and back of the muscle layer arrive at 20 μs and 60 μs. Find the thickness of the muscle.

The extra time for the pulse to cross the layer and come back is 60 − 20 = 40 μs.

Thickness = 1500 × 40 × 10⁻⁶ / 2 = 0.03, so 3.0 cm.

Specific acoustic impedance

The specific acoustic impedance Z of a medium is defined as

Z = ρc

It measures how strongly the medium resists being set into vibration. What matters for imaging is how different the impedances are on the two sides of a boundary.

The intensity reflection coefficient

The fraction of the incident intensity that is reflected at a boundary between media of impedances Z₁ and Z₂ is the intensity reflection coefficient:

I_R / I₀ = (Z₁ − Z₂)² / (Z₁ + Z₂)²

Read the expression before using it:

Why a coupling gel is used. Air has Z ≈ 430 kg m⁻² s⁻¹ and skin about 1.6 × 10⁶ kg m⁻² s⁻¹. Any air trapped between the transducer and the skin would reflect almost all the ultrasound before it entered the body. A gel whose impedance is close to that of skin is spread on first; it fills the gap and excludes the air, so nearly all the ultrasound passes into the body. This is impedance matching.

Worked example 3. Muscle has density 1075 kg m⁻³ and speed of sound 1590 m s⁻¹. Find its acoustic impedance.

Z = ρc = 1075 × 1590 = 1 709 250, so Z = 1.71 × 10⁶ kg m⁻² s⁻¹.

Worked example 4. Find the fraction of the intensity reflected at (a) a fat to muscle boundary, with Z = 1.34 × 10⁶ and 1.71 × 10⁶ kg m⁻² s⁻¹, (b) an air to skin boundary, with Z = 430 and 1.6 × 10⁶ kg m⁻² s⁻¹, and (c) a muscle to bone boundary, with bone Z = 7.75 × 10⁶ kg m⁻² s⁻¹.

(a) Working in units of 10⁶: (1.71 − 1.34)² / (1.71 + 1.34)² = 0.37² / 3.05² = 0.0147, so 1.5 per cent is reflected and 98.5 per cent transmitted.

(b) (1.6 × 10⁶ − 430)² / (1.6 × 10⁶ + 430)² = 0.9989, so 99.9 per cent is reflected. Without gel, almost nothing enters the body.

(c) (7.75 − 1.71)² / (7.75 + 1.71)² = 6.04² / 9.46² = 0.408, so 41 per cent is reflected, a strong echo, and less is left to image what lies behind bone.

The trap in every part is squaring only the numerator, or forgetting that the impedances must be in the same units.

Attenuation of ultrasound

As ultrasound travels through tissue its intensity falls, because energy is absorbed (converted to thermal energy) and scattered out of the beam. For a parallel beam the intensity falls exponentially with distance:

I = I₀e^(−μx)

A large μ means the beam is attenuated within a short distance. Attenuation rises with frequency, so there is a trade-off: higher frequencies give finer detail but cannot reach as deep. Scanners compensate by amplifying later echoes more than early ones.

Worked example 5. Soft tissue has μ = 23 m⁻¹ for a certain ultrasound frequency. A pulse travels to a muscle to bone boundary 4.5 cm deep and back. What fraction of the original intensity returns to the transducer? Ignore reflection at other boundaries.

The pulse travels 2 × 4.5 = 9.0 cm, so μx = 23 × 0.090 = 2.07.

Attenuation alone: e^(−2.07) = 0.126.

Only 41 per cent is reflected at the bone (worked example 4c), so the fraction returning is 0.41 × 0.126 = 0.052, about 5 per cent.

The trap is using the one-way depth, 4.5 cm, for x: the echo is attenuated on the way back too.

24.2 Production and use of X-rays

Producing X-rays

In an X-ray tube, electrons are emitted from a heated cathode (thermionic emission) and accelerated through a large potential difference, typically 20 to 150 kV, in a vacuum. They strike a metal target, usually tungsten, set into the anode. As the electrons are rapidly decelerated by the target atoms, they lose kinetic energy, and some of it is emitted as X-ray photons. This is X-ray production by electron bombardment of a metal target.

Only about 1 per cent of the electrons' energy becomes X-rays; the rest heats the target. Tungsten is chosen for its very high melting point, the anode is often rotated to spread the heating, and it is cooled.

Graph of relative X-ray intensity against wavelength in picometres for a tube at 80 kV. Nothing is emitted below a sharp cut-off at λmin = 15.5 pm; above it a smooth continuous spectrum rises to a maximum near 25 pm and falls away. Two sharp characteristic lines of the target metal stand on the curve near 18 and 21 pm.
Graph of relative X-ray intensity against wavelength in picometres for a tube at 80 kV. Nothing is emitted below a sharp cut-off at λmin = 15.5 pm; above it a smooth continuous spectrum rises to a maximum near 25 pm and falls away. Two sharp characteristic lines of the target metal stand on the curve near 18 and 21 pm.

The minimum wavelength

An electron accelerated through a p.d. V arrives at the target with kinetic energy eV. Most electrons lose this in many small steps, giving many lower-energy photons, which make up the continuous spectrum. The most energetic photon is produced when an electron loses all its kinetic energy in a single interaction. That photon has the highest frequency and therefore the minimum wavelength:

eV = hf_max = hc / λmin

λmin = hc / (eV)

The minimum wavelength depends only on the accelerating p.d. Raising V shortens λmin and makes the X-rays more penetrating ("harder"). The tube current, which is set by the heating of the cathode, controls how many electrons arrive per second and so the intensity of the beam, but not λmin. The target material does not affect λmin either; it decides the positions of the characteristic lines, which are not required here.

Worked example 6. An X-ray tube operates at 80 kV. Find the minimum wavelength of the X-rays.

λmin = hc / (eV) = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ × 3.00 × 10⁸ / (1.60 × 10⁻¹⁹ × 80 000) = 1.554 × 10⁻¹¹

so λmin = 1.55 × 10⁻¹¹ m (15.5 pm). The trap is using 80 instead of 80 000 V.

Worked example 7. What accelerating p.d. is needed for a minimum wavelength of 2.0 × 10⁻¹¹ m?

V = hc / (eλmin) = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ × 3.00 × 10⁸ / (1.60 × 10⁻¹⁹ × 2.0 × 10⁻¹¹) = 62 156

so V = 62 kV. A longer minimum wavelength needs a smaller p.d.

X-ray imaging and contrast

An X-ray image is a shadow picture. X-rays pass through the body and are attenuated by different amounts in different tissues; those that get through reach a detector or film, and the pattern of intensity forms the image. Where more X-rays arrive the image is darker; where fewer arrive (behind bone) it stays light.

Contrast is the difference in the degree of blackening (or brightness) between neighbouring regions of the image. Good contrast means that adjacent structures are easy to tell apart.

Contrast for soft tissue is improved with a contrast medium: a substance containing an element of high proton number, which attenuates X-rays strongly. A barium sulfate "meal" is swallowed to outline the stomach and intestines; an iodine compound injected into the blood outlines blood vessels. The organ filled with the medium then stands out against its surroundings. Contrast can also be adjusted through the tube voltage: lower-energy X-rays are attenuated more differently by different tissues, giving more contrast, but more of them are absorbed in the patient.

Attenuation of X-rays

A parallel X-ray beam is attenuated exponentially in the same way as ultrasound:

I = I₀e^(−μx)

with μ the linear attenuation coefficient of the material for that beam, in m⁻¹, and x the thickness of material, in m. Contrast exists because μ for bone is several times μ for soft tissue.

Worked example 8. For a certain X-ray beam, μ is 20 m⁻¹ for soft tissue and 60 m⁻¹ for bone. Compare the intensity transmitted through (a) 6.0 cm of soft tissue and (b) 3.0 cm of bone plus 3.0 cm of soft tissue.

(a) μx = 20 × 0.060 = 1.2, and e^(−1.2) = 0.301, so 30 per cent is transmitted.

(b) The exponents add for layers in sequence: 60 × 0.030 + 20 × 0.030 = 2.4, and e^(−2.4) = 0.0907, so 9.1 per cent is transmitted.

About 3.3 times as much radiation reaches the detector through the soft tissue alone, so the bone appears clearly lighter: that ratio is the contrast. The trap is to multiply the two coefficients together or add the thicknesses before applying one coefficient.

Computed tomography (CT) scanning

An ordinary X-ray image is a flat shadow: everything along the beam's path is superimposed, and depth is lost. CT scanning builds up a three-dimensional image of an internal structure, and the syllabus wants the stages in order:

  1. An X-ray tube and an array of detectors rotate around the patient, taking many X-ray images of the same section (slice) from different angles.
  2. A computer combines these images to produce a two-dimensional image of that section, showing where each feature lies within the slice.
  3. The patient is moved along the axis of rotation and the process is repeated for the next section, and so on along the region of interest.
  4. The computer combines the two-dimensional images of the many sections into a three-dimensional image of the structure.

Because the computer reconstructs the attenuation of each small volume of tissue, CT distinguishes soft tissues of slightly different attenuation that would be lost on a single image, and the 3D image can be rotated and sliced in any plane after the scan. The cost is a much higher radiation dose, because many exposures are taken.

24.3 PET scanning

Tracers

A tracer is a substance containing radioactive nuclei that can be introduced into the body, usually by injection, and is then absorbed by the tissue being studied. The most common tracer for positron emission tomography (PET) is a form of glucose in which one atom is replaced by fluorine-18. Tissue that uses glucose quickly, such as an active tumour or an active part of the brain, takes up more tracer.

The tracer used in PET decays by β⁺ decay, emitting a positron:

¹⁸₉F → ¹⁸₈O + ⁰₊₁e + ν

Fluorine-18 has a half-life of about 110 minutes: long enough to make the tracer and scan the patient, short enough that the patient's exposure is limited.

Annihilation

Annihilation occurs when a particle interacts with its antiparticle. Both are destroyed, and their total mass-energy is converted into photons. In the process both mass-energy and momentum are conserved.

In PET, a positron emitted by the tracer travels only a short distance, around a millimetre, losing its kinetic energy, and then meets an electron in the surrounding tissue. The two annihilate, producing two gamma-ray photons.

Momentum conservation is why there are two photons travelling in opposite directions. The electron and positron are nearly at rest, so the total momentum before annihilation is approximately zero. A single photon would carry momentum h / λ away in one direction, which is impossible. Two photons of equal energy moving in exactly opposite directions have a total momentum of zero, as required.

The energy of the gamma-ray photons

Assuming the electron and positron are at rest, their total energy is their rest-mass energy, 2mₑc². This is shared equally between two identical photons, so each has energy

E = mₑc²

Worked example 9. Calculate the energy of each gamma-ray photon produced when an electron and a positron annihilate at rest, in J and in MeV, and its wavelength.

E = mₑc² = 9.11 × 10⁻³¹ × (3.00 × 10⁸)² = 8.199 × 10⁻¹⁴ J, so E = 8.20 × 10⁻¹⁴ J.

In eV: 8.199 × 10⁻¹⁴ / (1.60 × 10⁻¹⁹) = 512 438, so E = 0.512 MeV (often quoted as 0.511 MeV with more precise constants).

λ = hc / E = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ × 3.00 × 10⁸ / (8.199 × 10⁻¹⁴) = 2.43 × 10⁻¹², so λ = 2.4 × 10⁻¹² m, firmly in the gamma-ray region.

The total energy released in the annihilation is twice this, 1.02 MeV. The trap is using the mass of both particles for the energy of one photon, or the mass of one for the total.

Forming the image

A ring of gamma-ray detectors around a cross-section of the patient. Inside tissue that has absorbed the tracer, an annihilation event sends two 0.51 MeV gamma-ray photons in opposite directions to detectors A and B on the line through the event. The event is nearer A, so its photon arrives at A first.
A ring of gamma-ray detectors around a cross-section of the patient. Inside tissue that has absorbed the tracer, an annihilation event sends two 0.51 MeV gamma-ray photons in opposite directions to detectors A and B on the line through the event. The event is nearer A, so its photon arrives at A first.
  1. The patient lies inside a ring of gamma-ray detectors.
  2. Positrons from the tracer annihilate with electrons in the tissue, each event producing two gamma-ray photons travelling in opposite directions.
  3. The gamma rays are penetrating, so they travel outside the body and are detected by two detectors on opposite sides of the ring. Two detections within a few nanoseconds of each other are taken to come from the same event, which must lie on the straight line joining the two detectors.
  4. The difference in the arrival times of the two photons locates the event along that line: the photon from an event nearer one detector arrives there first.
  5. A computer processes the arrival times from a very large number of events and builds up an image of the concentration of the tracer in the tissue. Regions with high tracer uptake, and so high metabolic activity, show up brightly.

PET therefore shows function (where the tracer is being used), whereas X-ray and CT images show structure. Combined PET-CT scanners overlay the two.

Worked example 10. Two detectors on opposite sides of a ring of diameter 0.80 m record the photons from one annihilation 0.40 ns apart. How far from the centre of the ring was the event?

Extra distance travelled by the later photon: 3.00 × 10⁸ × 0.40 × 10⁻⁹ = 0.12 m.

If the event is a distance x from the centre, one photon travels 0.40 + x and the other 0.40 − x, so the difference is 2x. Therefore x = 0.12 / 2 = 0.06, and the event is 6.0 cm from the centre, on the side of the detector that recorded first.

Worked example 11. To locate events to within 1.0 cm along the line, how precisely must the arrival times be compared?

A shift of 1.0 cm in x changes the path difference by 2.0 cm, so Δt = 0.020 / (3.00 × 10⁸) = 6.67 × 10⁻¹¹, about 0.07 ns. Real scanners time to a few hundred picoseconds, so the arrival times narrow the event down to a few centimetres along each line, and the image is completed by combining many lines through each point. The trap is forgetting the factor of 2.

Common mistakes

What the syllabus asks for on this topicSyllabus points

Syllabus points

24.1 Production and use of ultrasound

  • Understand that a piezo-electric crystal changes shape when a p.d. is applied across it and that the crystal generates an e.m.f. when its shape changes.
  • Understand how ultrasound waves are generated and detected by a piezoelectric transducer.
  • Understand how the reflection of pulses of ultrasound at boundaries between tissues can be used to obtain diagnostic information about internal structures.
  • Define the specific acoustic impedance of a medium as Z = ρc, where c is the speed of sound in the medium.
  • Use I_R / I₀ = (Z₁ − Z₂)² / (Z₁ + Z₂)² for the intensity reflection coefficient of a boundary between two media.
  • Recall and use I = I₀e^(−μx) for the attenuation of ultrasound in matter.

24.2 Production and use of X-rays

  • Explain that X-rays are produced by electron bombardment of a metal target and calculate the minimum wavelength of X-rays produced from the accelerating p.d.
  • Understand the use of X-rays in imaging internal body structures, including an understanding of the term contrast in X-ray imaging.
  • Recall and use I = I₀e^(−μx) for the attenuation of X-rays in matter.
  • Understand that computed tomography (CT) scanning produces a 3D image of an internal structure by first combining multiple X-ray images taken in the same section from different angles to obtain a 2D image of the section, then repeating this process along an axis and combining 2D images of multiple sections.

24.3 PET scanning

  • Understand that a tracer is a substance containing radioactive nuclei that can be introduced into the body and is then absorbed by the tissue being studied.
  • Recall that a tracer that decays by β⁺ decay is used in positron emission tomography (PET scanning).
  • Understand that annihilation occurs when a particle interacts with its antiparticle and that mass-energy and momentum are conserved in the process.
  • Explain that, in PET scanning, positrons emitted by the decay of the tracer annihilate when they interact with electrons in the tissue, producing a pair of gamma-ray photons travelling in opposite directions.
  • Calculate the energy of the gamma-ray photons emitted during the annihilation of an electron-positron pair.
  • Understand that the gamma-ray photons from an annihilation event travel outside the body and can be detected, and an image of the tracer concentration in the tissue can be created by processing the arrival times of the gamma-ray photons.

Related CIE 9702 Physics topics

Browse all CIE 9702 Physics revision notes →

Not the topic you were looking for? Describe what you are stuck on in your own words and we will take you to the notes that answer it.