Home / CIE 9702 Physics / Deformation of solids
CIE 9702 Physics · AS · Topic 6

Deformation of solids

CIE 9702 PhysicsASFree revision notes

Contents: 4 sections

Cambridge International AS & A Level Physics 9702 · AS

This topic describes how solids stretch and squash under load. It separates two ideas students often run together: the behaviour of a particular object (a spring, described by its spring constant) and the behaviour of a material (steel or copper, described by its Young modulus). It then deals with what happens beyond the elastic limit and with the energy stored in a deformed material. Forces and deformations are taken to act along one line only.

6.1 Stress and strain

Tensile and compressive forces

A solid is deformed when forces act on it to change its shape or size. In this syllabus the forces act along one line:

To stretch or squash an object that stays in place, equal and opposite forces must act at its two ends. A wire fixed to a ceiling and loaded at the bottom is stretched by the load at one end and the equal and opposite pull of the support at the other; the tension in the wire equals the load.

Load, extension, compression and limit of proportionality

Extension is never the total length. Subtracting the original length is the first step of most calculations in this topic, and the first thing people forget.

Hooke's law and the spring constant

Hooke's law: provided the limit of proportionality is not exceeded, the extension of an object is directly proportional to the force applied to it.

F = kx

The spring constant is the force per unit extension:

k = F / x

A large spring constant means a stiff object. On a graph of force against extension, k is the gradient of the straight-line section. On a graph of extension against force, which is how many experiments are plotted, the gradient is 1/k.

Worked example. A spring is 12.0 cm long when unloaded and 15.0 cm long when supporting a load of 6.0 N. Find the spring constant, assuming Hooke's law is obeyed.

Extension x = 15.0 − 12.0 = 3.0 cm = 0.030 m.

k = F / x = 6.0 N / 0.030 m = 200 N m⁻¹.

Using the stretched length, 6.0 / 0.150, gives 40 N m⁻¹, and that value is always among the options.

Worked example. Two identical springs, each with spring constant 200 N m⁻¹, support a load of 6.0 N side by side, sharing it equally. Find the extension and the spring constant of the pair.

Each spring carries 3.0 N, so each extends x = 3.0 / 200 = 0.015 m = 1.5 cm. The load moves down by 1.5 cm.

The pair: k = F / x = 6.0 / 0.015 = 400 N m⁻¹, twice that of one spring.

If instead the two springs are joined end to end, each carries the full 6.0 N and extends 3.0 cm, so the total extension is 6.0 cm and k = 6.0 / 0.060 = 100 N m⁻¹. In every arrangement the method is the same: work out the force each spring actually carries, then apply k = F / x to it.

Stress, strain and the Young modulus

The spring constant describes one object: a thicker or shorter wire of the same metal has a larger k. To describe the material, independently of the size of the sample, three quantities are used.

Stress is the force per unit cross-sectional area:

σ = F / A

Strain is the extension per unit original length:

ε = x / L

The Young modulus is the ratio of stress to strain, provided the limit of proportionality is not exceeded:

E = σ / ε = (F / A) / (x / L) = FL / Ax

The Young modulus is a property of the material, measuring its stiffness. Steel has E ≈ 2 × 10¹¹ Pa; rubber is thousands of times less stiff. A thick steel wire and a thin steel wire have the same Young modulus but different spring constants. On a stress-strain graph, E is the gradient of the straight-line region.

For a wire of diameter d, the cross-sectional area is A = πd² / 4 = πr². Halving the diameter quarters the area and so quadruples the stress for the same load.

A stress-strain graph for a metal wire. Stress, in units of 10 to the 8 pascals, from 0 to 4, is plotted against strain, in units of 10 to the minus 3, from 0 to 5. The graph is a straight line through the origin up to the limit of proportionality at a stress of 2.0 times 10 to the 8 pascals and a strain of 1.0 times 10 to the minus 3. Its gradient, the Young modulus, is 2.0 times 10 to the 11 pascals. Beyond this the line curves and flattens.
A stress-strain graph for a metal wire. Stress, in units of 10 to the 8 pascals, from 0 to 4, is plotted against strain, in units of 10 to the minus 3, from 0 to 5. The graph is a straight line through the origin up to the limit of proportionality at a stress of 2.0 times 10 to the 8 pascals and a strain of 1.0 times 10 to the minus 3. Its gradient, the Young modulus, is 2.0 times 10 to the 11 pascals. Beyond this the line curves and flattens.

Worked example. A wire of length 2.00 m and diameter 0.50 mm extends by 1.2 mm under a load of 25 N. Find the Young modulus of the material.

A = π × (0.25 × 10⁻³ m)² = 1.963 × 10⁻⁷ m².

Stress σ = F / A = 25 / (1.963 × 10⁻⁷) = 1.27 × 10⁸ Pa.

Strain ε = x / L = 1.2 × 10⁻³ / 2.00 = 6.0 × 10⁻⁴.

E = σ / ε = (1.27 × 10⁸) / (6.0 × 10⁻⁴) = 2.1 × 10¹¹ Pa.

Using the diameter as the radius makes the area four times too large and the answer four times too small. Forgetting to convert mm to m in the area gives an error of a factor of a million.

Worked example. A steel wire, Young modulus 2.0 × 10¹¹ Pa, is 3.0 m long with a diameter of 1.0 mm. Find its extension under a tension of 200 N.

A = π × (0.50 × 10⁻³)² = 7.85 × 10⁻⁷ m².

x = FL / AE = (200 × 3.0) / (7.85 × 10⁻⁷ × 2.0 × 10¹¹) = 600 / 157 000 = 3.8 × 10⁻³ m, so 3.8 mm.

Worked example. Wire P and wire Q are made of the same metal. Q is twice as long as P and has twice the diameter. They carry the same load. Find the ratio of the extension of Q to the extension of P.

From E = FL / Ax, the extension is x = FL / AE. F and E are the same for both.

Doubling L doubles x. Doubling d makes A four times larger, which divides x by 4.

x_Q / x_P = 2 / 4 = 0.5, so Q stretches half as much as P.

Experiment: determining the Young modulus of a metal wire

Apparatus. A long, thin wire (2 m to 3 m of copper or steel) clamped firmly at one end, passing over a pulley at the edge of the bench, with a mass hanger on its free end. A marker, such as a small strip of tape, is fixed to the wire near the pulley, with a metre rule fixed alongside it. (In Searle's apparatus, a vernier scale compares the test wire with a reference wire of the same material hanging beside it, which cancels any sag of the support and any thermal expansion.)

Apparatus for measuring the Young modulus of a wire. A long thin wire is clamped at the left end of a bench and runs horizontally for its original length L of about 2.5 m to a pulley at the right edge, where a mass hanger provides the load F. A marker on the wire near the pulley moves along a fixed scale, which measures the extension x. The diameter d is measured with a micrometer at several points.
Apparatus for measuring the Young modulus of a wire. A long thin wire is clamped at the left end of a bench and runs horizontally for its original length L of about 2.5 m to a pulley at the right edge, where a mass hanger provides the load F. A marker on the wire near the pulley moves along a fixed scale, which measures the extension x. The diameter d is measured with a micrometer at several points.

Measurements.

  1. Measure the original length L from the clamp to the marker with a metre rule or tape measure.
  2. Measure the diameter d with a micrometer screw gauge at several points along the wire and in two perpendicular directions at each point, and take the mean. Check the micrometer for a zero error first.
  3. With a small initial load to straighten the wire, record the marker position.
  4. Add loads in equal steps, for example 5 N, recording the marker position each time. The extension x is the change in position from the start.
  5. Remove the loads in the same steps and record the readings again. If they return to the original values, the wire has not passed its elastic limit.

Analysis. Plot a graph of F against x. In the straight-line region the gradient is F / x, so:

E = gradient × L / A, with A = πd² / 4.

Alternatively calculate stress and strain for each reading and plot stress against strain: the gradient is E directly.

Controlled variables and precautions. Use the same wire throughout and keep the temperature constant. Do not exceed the limit of proportionality. Wear eye protection, since a wire under tension can snap and whip, and keep feet clear of the hanging masses.

Main uncertainties. The extension is small, often a millimetre or two, so it has the largest percentage uncertainty: this is why the wire is long (larger extension for the same strain) and thin (larger stress for the same load). The diameter has the next largest effect, because it is squared in the area, so its percentage uncertainty counts twice.

Worked example. In the wire experiment above, d = 0.50 ± 0.01 mm, x = 1.2 ± 0.1 mm, L = 2.000 ± 0.002 m and F = 25.0 ± 0.1 N. Estimate the percentage uncertainty in E.

Total = 4 + 8.3 + 0.1 + 0.4 = 12.8%, so about 13%. E = (2.1 ± 0.3) × 10¹¹ Pa.

The extension dominates, so the most effective improvement is to measure it more precisely, for example with a vernier scale or travelling microscope, or to use a longer wire.

6.2 Elastic and plastic behaviour

Elastic and plastic deformation

The limit of proportionality and the elastic limit are different ideas, and questions set them against each other. The limit of proportionality is about the shape of the graph: the end of the straight line. The elastic limit is about whether the object recovers. For a metal wire the two are close together, with the elastic limit at or just beyond the limit of proportionality. Rubber is an example of a material that deforms elastically over a large extension without obeying Hooke's law at all.

A force-extension graph for a metal wire, force in newtons from 0 to 60 against extension in millimetres from 0 to 5. The graph is straight from the origin to the limit of proportionality at 40 N and 2.0 mm. The triangle under this section is shaded: its area, one half times 40 N times 2.0 mm, is 0.040 J, the work done and the elastic potential energy stored. The elastic limit is marked just beyond, at about 44 N and 2.3 mm, and the curve then flattens in the region of plastic deformation.
A force-extension graph for a metal wire, force in newtons from 0 to 60 against extension in millimetres from 0 to 5. The graph is straight from the origin to the limit of proportionality at 40 N and 2.0 mm. The triangle under this section is shaded: its area, one half times 40 N times 2.0 mm, is 0.040 J, the work done and the elastic potential energy stored. The elastic limit is marked just beyond, at about 44 N and 2.3 mm, and the curve then flattens in the region of plastic deformation.

When a metal is loaded beyond its elastic limit and then unloaded, the unloading line is parallel to the original straight line, but it reaches zero force at a non-zero extension. That intercept on the extension axis is the permanent extension.

A force-extension graph showing loading and unloading beyond the elastic limit. Force in newtons from 0 to 60 is plotted against extension in millimetres from 0 to 6. Loading follows a straight line to 40 N at 2.0 mm, then curves up to 50 N at 5.0 mm. Unloading from that point follows a straight line parallel to the first, reaching zero force at 2.5 mm, which is the permanent extension.
A force-extension graph showing loading and unloading beyond the elastic limit. Force in newtons from 0 to 60 is plotted against extension in millimetres from 0 to 6. Loading follows a straight line to 40 N at 2.0 mm, then curves up to 50 N at 5.0 mm. Unloading from that point follows a straight line parallel to the first, reaching zero force at 2.5 mm, which is the permanent extension.

Work done and the area under a force-extension graph

When a force stretches an object, it does work, because its point of application moves. The force is not constant, so W = Fs cannot be used directly. Instead:

The work done in deforming an object is the area under the force-extension graph.

This is true for any shape of graph, whether or not Hooke's law is obeyed. For a curved graph, the area is found by counting squares, or by splitting it into triangles and trapeziums, and multiplying by the energy that one square represents.

For the loading and unloading graph above, the work done in loading is the area under the loading curve; the energy returned during unloading is the area under the unloading line. The difference, the area between the two lines, is energy that has been transferred to internal energy of the wire and is not recovered.

Elastic potential energy

If the deformation is elastic, the work done is stored in the object as elastic potential energy (strain energy), and it is returned when the load is removed: a stretched catapult or a compressed spring can do work.

Within the limit of proportionality the force-extension graph is a straight line through the origin, so the area under it is a triangle of base x and height F:

E_P = ½Fx

Substituting F = kx:

E_P = ½kx²

The ½ is essential. The force starts at zero and rises steadily to F, so the average force during the stretch is F / 2. Writing E_P = Fx gives an answer twice too large.

Because E_P depends on x², doubling the extension quadruples the energy stored. These formulae only apply within the limit of proportionality. Beyond it the graph is no longer a triangle, so the energy must be found from the area under the graph.

Worked example. A spring of spring constant 200 N m⁻¹ is stretched by 4.0 cm. Find the elastic potential energy stored, and the extra energy needed to stretch it to 8.0 cm.

At 4.0 cm: E_P = ½kx² = ½ × 200 × 0.040² = 0.16 J.

At 8.0 cm: E_P = ½ × 200 × 0.080² = 0.64 J, so the extra energy needed is 0.64 − 0.16 = 0.48 J.

Doubling the extension took three times as much extra energy as the first 4.0 cm, because the force is larger throughout the second stretch.

Worked example. Use the force-extension graph above to find the energy stored in the wire when it is stretched to its limit of proportionality.

At the limit of proportionality, F = 40 N and x = 2.0 mm = 2.0 × 10⁻³ m.

E_P = ½Fx = ½ × 40 × 2.0 × 10⁻³ = 0.040 J.

Leaving the extension in mm gives 40 J, a thousand times too large. Always convert the extension to metres before calculating energy.

Worked example. The wire in the Young modulus example above (load 25 N, extension 1.2 mm, within the limit of proportionality) stores how much energy?

E_P = ½Fx = ½ × 25 × 1.2 × 10⁻³ = 0.015 J.

Common mistakes

Check you have it

Question 1

The force–extension graph for a wire is shown. Which row could identify the labels X, Y and Z? Each answer gives, in order: limit of proportionality; region of elastic deformation; region of plastic deformation.

Diagram from the Cambridge Physics 9702 Paper 1 October/November 2023 paper, variant 2, question 19.

Question 2

A sample of material is stretched by a tensile force to a point beyond its elastic limit. The tensile force is then reduced to zero. The force–extension graph is shown. Which area represents the net work done on the sample?

Diagram from the Cambridge Physics 9702 Paper 1 May/June 2024 paper, variant 3, question 20.

Question 3

A known tensile force acts on a metal wire. The wire does not exceed its limit of proportionality.
Which two measurements enable the strain of the wire to be calculated?

What the syllabus asks for on this topicSyllabus points

Syllabus points

6.1 Stress and strain

  • Understand that deformation is caused by tensile or compressive forces, with forces and deformations in one dimension only.
  • Understand and use the terms load, extension, compression and limit of proportionality.
  • Recall and use Hooke's law.
  • Recall and use the formula for the spring constant k = F / x.
  • Define and use the terms stress, strain and the Young modulus.
  • Describe an experiment to determine the Young modulus of a metal in the form of a wire.

6.2 Elastic and plastic behaviour

  • Understand and use the terms elastic deformation, plastic deformation and elastic limit.
  • Understand that the area under the force-extension graph represents the work done.
  • Determine the elastic potential energy of a material deformed within its limit of proportionality from the area under the force-extension graph.
  • Recall and use E_P = ½Fx = ½kx² for a material deformed within its limit of proportionality.

Related CIE 9702 Physics topics

Browse all CIE 9702 Physics revision notes →

Not the topic you were looking for? Describe what you are stuck on in your own words and we will take you to the notes that answer it.