IB Economics Paper 1: 10 and 15 Mark Structure
Contents: 7 sections
What Paper 1 asks of you
Paper 1 is the extended response paper, based on all units of the syllabus. Standard Level and Higher Level students each sit their own Paper 1, and the two have the same structure:
- 1 hour 15 minutes, 25 marks. No calculator is allowed.
- Three questions, and you answer one. Each question is set on a different part of the course, so you choose the one you can answer best. There are no sections.
- Weighting: 30% of the final grade at Standard Level and 20% at Higher Level.
Every question comes in two parts:
- Part (a), 10 marks. An explanation task. You are asked to explain a concept or mechanism.
- Part (b), 15 marks. An evaluation task. You are asked to discuss, evaluate, or judge to what extent something holds, using real-world examples.
The two parts are marked against different markbands, and they reward different things. In our experience the most common mistake is writing part (b) in the style of part (a): more theory, more diagrams, no judgement.
Part (a): the 10-mark explanation
Part (a) is not an essay. It is a controlled explanation, and its markband rewards three things: understanding of what the question asks, relevant theory that is explained rather than just described, and economic terms used appropriately, with a relevant diagram where one fits. It does not reward evaluation, and it does not ask for a real-world example, so time spent on either is time taken from the explanation.
A reliable order to work in (this is our advice, not an IB rule):
1. Define the terms in the question. Every key term, briefly and precisely. If the question says "explain how a subsidy affects a market", define subsidy.
2. Draw and fully label a diagram, where the question suits one. Name both axes, label every curve, mark the initial and new equilibrium, and show the direction of any shift with an arrow.
3. Explain the mechanism as a chain. Do not state the outcome; walk from cause to effect, one link at a time:
- A subsidy lowers producers' costs
- supply shifts right from S1 to S2
- at the original price there is now excess supply
- price falls from P1 to P2 and quantity traded rises from Q1 to Q2.
Writing each link makes the explanation complete. "A subsidy increases supply so price falls" compresses four steps into one and reads as description rather than explanation.
4. Refer to the diagram in the writing. "As the diagram shows, supply shifts from S1 to S2…" ties the two together.
Part (b): the 15-mark evaluation
Part (b) is marked on whether you weigh the issue and reach a judgement, supported by real-world examples. Its markband moves from an answer with no evaluation, through evaluation that is superficial, then appropriate but one-sided, to evaluation that is effective and balanced; real-world examples move from merely identified to fully developed in the context of the question. The structure below is front-loaded, so if you run out of time your analysis is already on the page.
1. A one-sentence definition and a statement of the position you will argue. Do not write a long introduction. Say what the answer depends on.
2. Analysis: build two developed chains. One supporting, one qualifying. Each gets a diagram if the economics warrants one, and each is written as cause → mechanism → consequence, exactly as in part (a).
3. Application: anchor it in the real world. A named country, policy, industry or episode, with a specific detail, used to support the argument rather than mentioned in passing.
4. Evaluation: reasoning about conditions. Evaluation is not a list of disadvantages. Useful lines:
- It depends on elasticity. How responsive are the parties? A tax on a price-inelastic good cuts consumption far less.
- Short run versus long run. Does the effect reverse, fade, or compound over time?
- Who gains and who loses? Consumers, producers, government, workers, future generations.
- Assumptions. What does the model take as given (perfect information, rational behaviour, ceteris paribus), and what happens when that fails?
- Priorities and trade-offs. Efficiency against equity; growth against sustainability; one macro objective against another.
5. A conditional judgement. Not "in conclusion, it has advantages and disadvantages." A judgement states when the answer holds:
A subsidy is most likely to raise welfare where the positive externality is large and demand is relatively elastic, so the output gain is significant. Where demand is inelastic and the government is financing it by cutting other spending, the opportunity cost may exceed the external benefit.
What moves an answer up the bands
| Dimension | What a strong answer shows |
|---|---|
| Terminology | Key terms defined accurately and then used correctly throughout. |
| Theory and diagrams | Theory explained, not just described; diagrams correct, fully labelled and referred to in the prose. |
| Application (part b) | Specific, named real-world material, developed in the context of the question. |
| Evaluation (part b) | Balanced reasoning about conditions, ending in a judgement that follows from the analysis. |
A diagram that is drawn but never mentioned in the writing does little work. Refer to it directly.
Common ways students lose marks
- Starting more than one question. You answer one, in two parts.
- Treating part (b) as a longer part (a): more theory, more diagrams, no judgement.
- Spending part (a) time on evaluation or real-world examples that its markband does not reward.
- Listing evaluation points as disadvantages rather than reasoning about conditions.
- Leaving axes or curves unlabelled.
- A conclusion that restates the introduction instead of deciding anything.
- Spending so long on part (a) that part (b), worth half as much again, is rushed.
How to plan under time pressure
This is our suggested approach, not an IB requirement.
Spend the first few minutes choosing the question you can support with a real-world example in part (b), not the topic you like most. Then sketch, in the margin: the diagram for (a), and for (b) your two chains plus the condition your judgement will turn on.
With 75 minutes for 25 marks, a split of roughly 30 minutes for part (a) and 40 for part (b), after a few minutes of planning, keeps part (b), worth half as much again, from being rushed.
Practise this
The fastest way to improve on Paper 1 is to plan many answers rather than write a few. Build the definition, the chain, the example and the judgement for a question. Check it, then move on.
The Answer Builder in the portal does exactly this: it walks you through the four steps for a 15-mark question and coaches each one, so you practise the reasoning before writing under timed conditions.
Related IB Economics topics
Not the topic you were looking for? Describe what you are stuck on in your own words and we will take you to the notes that answer it.
